It's Diane Kruger vs Debra Messing in Gaultier belted dress

There's nothing I love more than a celebrity fashion face-off and I've got a beauty here in Debra Messing and Diane Kruger. The shades may look different but after going back though the Shiny fashion archives I noticed that both actresses were spotted out wearing identical Jean Paul Gaultier belted purple frocks.

Debra chose to wear hers at the unveiling of Saks Fifth Avenue new shoe department with a chunky black bag while Diane (who was snapped in it first) wore hers to the Cartier International Polo Day, accessorising with a rather tasty looking Joshua Jackson.

The question here is who do you think pulled it of better? Does Debra's gorgeous red hair complement the dress enough to swing it for you or do you prefer Diane's relaxed style with loose locks and an added black patent belt?